Picking Winners and Losers | General News & Politics | Hudson Valley | Chronogram Magazine

News & Politics » General News & Politics

Picking Winners and Losers

Body Politic September 2018



In June 1982, a Chrysler supervisor and his son, who had been laid off at a Michigan auto plant, killed a Chinese American man, thinking he was Japanese.

Back in the 1970s and 1980s, we feared Japan, Inc. That country's companies, backed by government planning and assistance, and in cooperation with their banks, had targeted a set of industries, committed themselves to developing them, and was beating American companies. More often than not, their victories came where American inventions had led the way.

The response, in America, was not to look and learn. It was to complain that the Japanese were using unfair trade practices. No doubt they were. On the other hand, no US auto company was making cars as good as theirs. US labor costs were burdened by health care benefits, but US auto companies did not lobby for a national health system like the Japanese to get out from under that. Things didn't get any better. In 1995, the Clinton administration announced 100-percent tariffs on 13 Japanese luxury cars. They did not go into effect, because Japan's auto companies leapt over their own government and went into direct negotiations.

Here we are again. Now it's China!

The fact is that every country that has achieved a successful modern economy has done so with a combination of protectionism and government support of targeted industries. That includes those verbal champions of free trade, Britain and the United States, as well as France, Germany, Japan, South Korea, and Brazil.

One of China's targeted industries is solar power. Their companies now account for around 60 percent of total annual solar cell manufacturing. Seven of the top 10 solar panel manufacturers are in China. It's a good choice. Solar power is one of the fastest growing industries in the world. The estimated value of solar power in 2015 was $86 billion. It's projected to hit $422 billion by 2022. There's no reason to expect it to stop there. With climate change, air and water pollution, the world will become more insistent on counting the external costs of using fossil fuels. There's every reason to expect solar to continue to grow.

Most solar power systems are based on the silicon photovoltaic cell. They were first created at Bell Labs in 1954. They were improved enough to be used in satellites by Hoffman Electronics in Los Angeles. They are measured by how efficiently they convert sunlight to electricity. The most efficient ones in the world came out last year, developed by the US Department of Energy and Spectrolab, a subsidiary of Boeing.

If America invents things, why do other countries end up with the businesses?


China has deliberate, conscious, industrial development policies. They are modeled on what South Korea did. South Korea modeled themselves on Japan.

Mitt Romney loved to say, "Government should not pick winners and losers!" Paul Ryan says it, too. Packs of Republican senators say it all together. It's a gospel song at right-wing think tanks. When one of the solar companies that the Obama administration backed, Solyndra, went bankrupt, the Republicans beat at him with it the way they beat at Hillary with Benghazi.

They don't mean it.

Tax policies created the piles of investor money that made Mitt Romney's Bain Capital happen. Then they let Mitt pay a lower percentage in taxes than an ordinary working person. When the Crash of 2008 came, the US Treasury committed hundreds of billions to saving the big banks and financial companies. The Federal Reserve put trillions of dollars into the same hands. They did save GM and Chrysler, but they did not make that money available to the industrial sector generally, to small and medium-sized businesses, to developing the technologies of the future, or to the homeowners who were suddenly in trouble.

The US government gives immense support to defense companies. Many of those companies invest heavily in research and development with our government's money. It's created much of America's technological edge. Many of those companies actually make things—often employing people at decent wages—and many of them, like Boeing, have one wing on the military side and the other on the civilian side, and they're among our most successful sectors. In the name of defense, the US has subsidized oil companies, shaped foreign policy, and engaged in war.

In 2012, the New York Times published an interactive feature "$100 Million Club," naming 48 companies that have received at least that much from the states, separately from the federal government. The list includes GM, Ford, Shell Oil, Caterpillar, BMW, Mercedes Benz, Microsoft, Airbus, Panasonic, Amazon, Google, Michelin, Sears, and Dow. Towns and counties also give out deals.

When Jimmy Carter came into office, there was an oil crisis. He asked for $100 billion to invest in solar research. He installed solar panels in the White House.

He lost to Ronald Reagan. Reagan removed the solar panels. He returned policy to whomever had the most financial clout to buy it. There it has remained, for the most part, ever since.

Speaking of Larry Beinhart, body Politic

Add a comment

Latest in News & Politics

  • Celebrating Juneteenth 2021 in the Hudson Valley
  • Celebrating Juneteenth 2021 in the Hudson Valley

    Juneteenth marks the official end of slavery in America on June 19, 1865. Today, the holiday focuses on Black achievements and culture, recognition of inequality and systemic racism in the United States, and the ongoing fight for equal rights. 2021 brings an expanded list of ways to celebrate Black freedom and to reckon with the racial past and present of the United States.
    • Jun 14, 2021
  • Clarkson’s Beacon Institute Is Moving to Its New Home at Dennings Point This Month
  • Clarkson’s Beacon Institute Is Moving to Its New Home at Dennings Point This Month

    For over a decade, Clarkson University’s Beacon Institute has been a mainstay of downtown Beacon. From its location on Main Street, the Institute has become a leading voice in research into healthy water solutions in the region and has been an important local resource for STEM-driven educational programs for K-12 students, families, and the public alike. This June marks a major milestone for the growth of the Institute, as it officially relocates just a few miles south to Dennings Point—a scenic 64-acre peninsula that juts into the Hudson River and is part of the Hudson Highlands State Park.
    • Jun 5, 2021
  • Winnakee Land Trust Opens Vlei Marsh to the Public
  • Winnakee Land Trust Opens Vlei Marsh to the Public

    The Winnakee Land Trust opened Vlei Marsh to the public on June 1, a 165-acre nature preserve that is Rhinebeck’s second largest wetland area. Multi-looped, newly upgraded trails at Vlei Marsh take visitors through both wetland and forest, home to scores of mammals, amphibians, and birds. A 30-year-old accredited land trust and nonprofit, the WLT focuses on protecting and stewarding forests, farmland, natural habitats, and water resources from development, for both ecological health and community enjoyment. They have expanded into acquiring and maintaining land in the Hudson Valley in the past few years.
    • Jun 3, 2021